One of college football’s fiercest rivalries has sparked a membership challenge between National Guard associations in two states.
“The Game,” as it is known among fans, pits the University of Michigan Wolverines and the Ohio State University Buckeyes against each other. This year, it is Nov. 28 in Columbus, Ohio.
The membership contest is between the National Guard Association of Michigan, a joint officer and enlisted association, and the Ohio National Guard Association and the Ohio National Guard Enlisted Association.
The stakes are high in both competitions. It’s more than bragging rights — both sides hate losing to the other more than they love winning.
Michigan and Ohio State first played football in 1897 and have met every year since 1918. The Wolverines lead the all-time series 62-52-6, but the Buckeyes have won 18 of the 25 games since 2000.
Both are among the blue bloods of the sport. Michigan took the national championship in 2023. Ohio State won it in 2024 but lost to the Wolverines in the regular season, which diminished the accomplishment in the eyes of many of its fans.
ESPN notes that the annual regular-season finale “transcends college football as one of the biggest and most heated matchups in all of American sports.”
That heat stems from a combination of historical border conflict, decades of championship stakes and deeply ingrained cultural traditions.
Long before the teams first met, the two states fought a nearly bloodless boundary dispute in 1835 over the Toledo Strip. Congress eventually awarded the land to Ohio and gave Michigan the Upper Peninsula as a compromise, setting up a lasting interstate grudge.
That grudge is evident during the Roll Call of States at the annual NGAUS conference. Representatives from the two states never fail to take a jab at each other when it’s their turn at the microphone.
Now, there’s a membership challenge to harness the passion at the core of the rivalry.
“It’s a way we can we generate more growth in both organizations and have fun doing it,” said Lt. Col. Patrick Hernandez, the ONGA president and an OSU grad, who playfully refers to Michiganders as “the people up north.”
The challenge began Sept. 1 and runs through Saturday. Each state earns one point for a new complimentary NGAUS or Enlisted Association of the National Guard of the United States membership, two points for an annual membership and five points for a lifetime membership.
Prizes will go to the units that recruit the most new members and to the individuals who refer them.
But it is fear of losing that is generating interest, said Hernandez and T.J. Pierce, the NGAM executive director.
The adjutant general, senior enlisted advisor, association president and executive director of the losing association must wear the opposing team’s jersey and recite their motto on video.
Hernandez described it as a “punishment.”
However, he added, “If it bolsters membership in one or both of our organizations, I’m more than willing to fall on that sword.”
Pierce agrees on the potential pain of losing the competition.
“The thought of putting Ohio State’s scarlet and gray on and doing their Ohio chant brings me physical pain right now,” he said, laughing. “I don’t know if my kids would ever look at me again. But it’s just the same for them. I guarantee nobody down there wants to wear maize and blue.”
Ohio led the competition until the Michigan association held its annual state conference earlier this month, where roughly 150 new life memberships put Michigan in front.
“It’s not over until it’s over,” Pierce added. “Until we get to 2359 hours on Saturday, November 21, this isn’t done. So, I’m not counting Ohio out.”
—By John Goheen